Photo by Jan van der Wolf
San Francisco embraced shared e-scooters and e-bikes in 2018, promising a cleaner, quicker first- and last-mile commute. Yet “lightweight” doesn’t mean “low-risk.” A recent UCSF study found e-bike injuries doubled every year from 2017 to 2022, while e-scooter injuries rose 45 percent annually.
Within the city, the latest SFMTA crash bulletin shows injury collisions involving stand-up powered devices leaping from 95 in 2020 to 227 in 2024—a 139 percent jump. The steep grades of Nob Hill, the street-car tracks on Market, and a patchwork of bike lanes create a perfect storm where small wheels meet big trouble.
What the Data Tell Us
- Volume is exploding. National shared-micromobility trips passed 130 million rides in 2023, up nearly four-fold since 2017, according to the National Association of City Transportation Officials.
- Head injuries dominate. In Austin’s landmark CDC study, almost half of 271 injured scooter riders sustained head trauma, and only 1 in 190 wore a helmet.
- Emergency-room visits are soaring. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission tallied over 360,000 micromobility-related ER visits between 2017 and 2023.
- Cyclists remain at risk. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration data show bicyclist deaths hitting 1,166 in 2023—the highest since 1980.
These numbers confirm what every campus commuter senses: the convenience dividend is being paid in fractured wrists, concussions, and ICU bills.
Design Over Blame—Ethical Fixes for Safer Streets
Geofenced “slow streets.” Los Angeles proved the concept by capping scooter speed to 8 mph in high-pedestrian zones, reducing crash calls 19 percent in a year. Adopting similar digital speed governors around Civic Center and the Embarcadero would tame the city’s fastest corridors without banning devices outright.
Side-guard standards for delivery trucks. Even at scooter speeds, a collision with a box truck is lethal. Boston’s mandatory side-guards cut truck-bike fatalities 23 percent within three years. Extending the rule through San Francisco’s Vision Zero Freight program would protect couriers and casual riders alike.
Battery-fire mitigation. Lithium-ion fires from aftermarket e-bike packs have spiked in New York. UL-certified charging lockers in Mission District apartment basements could stop a similar tragedy before it starts, aligning with the city’s Climate Action goals.
Inclusive pavement design. Slip-resistant thermoplastic on rail crossings and color-differentiated bike lanes—already piloted on Townsend Street—help tiny scooter wheels stay upright on fog-slick mornings. Ethical design means planning for the least stable vehicle, not the most robust.
When a Ride Becomes a Lawsuit
Confusion over fault is common: Is it the rider who swerved, the platform that failed to fix a broken brake, or the city that left a crater in the bike lane? Because liability can ricochet among multiple parties, injured residents often turn to a San Francisco personal injury lawyer like J&Y Law to decipher maintenance logs, app telemetry, and municipal permits.
Key legal considerations include:
- Product defect (e.g., sudden battery cutoff).
- Negligent maintenance by fleet operators.
- Dangerous public property under California Government Code § 835.
- Comparative negligence if the rider ignored helmet or speed rules.
Settlement values hinge on medical documentation; emergency-department records linking head CT scans to crash timestamps become exhibit A. Riders should photograph the scene, preserve the scooter’s QR code, and file a police report—even if they walk away seemingly unscathed. TBIs often surface hours later.
The Campus-City Compact
Santa Clara University trains engineers and ethicists under one roof—an ideal incubator for micromobility solutions. Students could:
- Map “near-miss” heat-spots using anonymized ride data shared under the city’s Emerging Mobility Permit.
- Develop AI-vision add-ons that flash a warning when riders enter rail grooves or potholes.
- Prototype collapsible, styrofoam-free helmets that clip to backpack straps, tackling the “I didn’t have one with me” excuse from the Austin study.
City planners, meanwhile, can leverage university research grants to run real-world pilots on low-traffic evenings, turning Mission Campus roads into a living lab. The payoff is measurable: every prevented concussion saves roughly $15,000 in acute medical costs, the CDC estimates, and reduces lifetime cognitive-impairment risk.
Toward a Shared-Safety Future
Micromobility is no fad; e-bike sales now outpace electric-car sales nationwide. But adopting tech faster than we adapt infrastructure magnifies harm. San Francisco’s rolling hills may never be as e-scooter-friendly as Copenhagen’s flats, yet data-driven street design and clear legal pathways can narrow the injury gap.
If UCSF’s doubling-injury curve is a warning bell, ethical design is the hand that hits the brakes, and robust legal remedies are the guardrails that catch us when design fails. The city that pioneered the cable car can surely engineer a safer glide path for 21st-century wheels—one where convenience no longer comes at the cost of blood, litigation, and lost semesters.
Leave a Reply