Not everyone is good at storytelling. My sister, for example, remembers the most random and irrelevant details of events and pieces them together in a way that only makes sense to her. And if it is a funny story, you can pretty much forget about anticipating the punchline.
Now, piecing information together to write an essay is kind of like storytelling… except that it is not. For research, you can’t just simply weave the ideas of your sources together and expect to create something that is original or thought provoking. If you just quilt together the information you’ve read, you might as well just turn in a list of sources or Works Cited page and tell your professor to read that instead.
Research is telling your own story. If you like the quilting analogy, think of your sources as the thread and the material you sew together is something you’ve created yourself. For my writing class we had to read an article by Margret Krantz that said just that… research is all about using your sources persuasively.
But wait! Persuasive doesn’t mean right or wrong, nor does it mean for or against. Rather, like the quilt, it means arguing something that you’ve made, arguing your own original ideas. Krantz points out you can’t just take information from sources as the truth because context is so important. Ask yourself; Who is the author speaking to? Why are they writing this? These questions help uncover a lot of the context of your article.
A great activity my writing class did one day was look at two different sources and discern which was bullshit and which was a respectable option for a theoretical Works Cited page. The most shocking was two webpages about Martin Luther King Jr. One was titled “Marin Luther King: A True Historical Examination” and the other was Wikipedia. All my classmates and I originally hated on Wikipedia and decided there would be no way we would put that on our Works Cited page… Let’s just say sorry Wikipedia. Accidentally citing a KKK website for your research article on MLK might be the biggest faux pas to ever happen.
After looking at my own sources, although none of them are sponsored by the KKK, they all pretty much come from the same place: a scholarly journal writing to other scholars. This realization sucks for me 🙁 because I am pretty much getting the same perspective. My database aimed at research, I just failed myself by not looking into other options to find my sources.
Here we go – source hunting round 2.